Showing posts with label Yom Kippur. Show all posts
Showing posts with label Yom Kippur. Show all posts

Sunday, September 20, 2026

Yom Kippur: The Goat at the End

I want to start off by saying how impressed I was with so many of the divrei Torahs this year. Due to time constraints, I put them into word docs each week and printed them off to read on Shabbas, so I apologize for not having the wherewithal after to go back and send regards/thoughts/compliments.

It’s hard to think of what to write for Yom Kippur. There is so much to say and yet so much has already been said. Also, many of us don’t have time to sit down and read a long Dvar Torah right now. Erev Yom Kippur, at least in my household, has always ended up being a bizarrely busy day. (So what are you all cooking for the seuda, anyway?!?) And here I go, already making excuses for why my preparation was, perhaps, a little shoddy…here I go using my household as my scapegoat.

Ok, that’s, perhaps, a flexible definition of the idea of a scapegoat, but what better time than Yom Kippur to discuss this puzzling and mysterious ritual. To the 21st century ear, it sounds highly...archaic, especially when one looks at the mepharshim that explain Azazel as a demon…

The fact of the matter is that the entire ritual is one that commentators in almost every generation have had to strive to understand. Not only is there debate over what the term Azazel means, but the actual fate of the goat is argued. Some sources describe the goat being thrown from a cliff in such a way that it was torn apart by the time it was halfway down the mountain (described by Rabbi Eliyahu Munk* as having a stone tied to its horn so that it was walloped after it was shoved off the cliff). On the other hand, there are sources that describe the goat being released into a bleak wilderness where it would slowly die from lack of food and water.  Whether you are disturbed by the idea of sending a sacrifice to a demon (or a representative of the satan) or by the seemingly blatant tzar baalei chaim, the fact of the matter remains that the ceremony of the two goats is an integral aspect of Yom Kippur.

 To briefly address the idea of Azazel as a who rather than a place, the following idea is from ravkooktorah.org: The abstract knowledge that evil also has a purpose in the world must be acknowledged in some fashion in our service of God. This acknowledgment occurs in the elevated service of Yom Kippur. In practical ethics, however, there is no place for this knowledge. Heaven forbid that evil should be considered good, or that the wicked should be considered righteous. Therefore, the goat for Azazel was sent to a desolate, barren place — a place uninhabited by people. Human society must be based on a just way of life, led by aspirations of holiness and purity. (Gold from the Land of Israel, pp. 200-201. Adapted from Olat Re’iyah vol. II p. 357; Shemonah Kevatzim IV:91, V:193)

 Our aspirations are toward holiness and purity, so it is important for us to wrap our 21st century brains around this significant ritual. What were we doing with these goats?

 Let’s review the basics. Two goats, as alike in appearance as possible, were brought before the Kohen Gadol. Lots were drawn to determine which fate belonged to which goat. One goat was taken and offered as a korban. The other goat was then burdened, so to speak, with the sins of klal Yisrael and sent off to Azazel. Here’s another strange bit. What does it mean that the sins of Klal Yisrael were placed on the goat?

 Rabbi Lord Jonathan Sacks notes that Sin and guilt offerings are familiar features of the Torah and a normal part of the service of the Temple. The service of Yom Kippur was different in one salient respect: in every other case, the sin was confessed over the animal that was sacrificed. On Yom Kippur, the High Priest confessed the sins of the people over the animal that was not sacrificed, the scapegoat that was sent away, “carrying on it all their iniquities” (Lev. 16:21-22).

 Here is another question… this part of the avodah of Yom Kippur occurred around midday, when already the people were already afflicting themselves as commanded by the Torah to bring kapara, so wasn’t the personal acts of devotion enough?

 There are, perhaps, two ways of looking at these questions. Rabbi Sacks presents an interesting idea: Yom Kippur deals not only with our sins as individuals. It also confronts our sins as a community bound by mutual responsibility. It deals, in other words, with the social as well as the personal dimension of wrongdoing. Yom Kippur is about shame as well as guilt. Hence there has to be purification (the removal of the stain) as well as atonement…Shame cannot be removed by forgiveness. The victim of our crime may have forgiven us, but we still feel defiled by the knowledge that our name has been disgraced, our reputation harmed, our standing damaged. We still feel the stigma, the dishonour, the degradation. That is why an immensely powerful and dramatic ceremony had to take place during which people could feel and symbolically see their sins carried away to the desert…”

 But perhaps there are also the personal sins involved. Let’s be honest, as Yom Kippur approaches we all try our hardest to do honest teshuva but are aware that it is probable that the aveiros we need to ask mechila for are ones that we don’t actually remember. To that end, we casually walk around and approach people we know and ask for blanket mechila – you know, for anything I might have done to hurt you. Here we are on Yom Kippur seeking out mechila and kapara and we aren’t even sure for what. Perhaps, and this is my own humble thought and not sourced, perhaps these were the types of sins “collected” by the Kohen Gadol and placed upon the goat.

 This little goat has a lot to bear but let us look at one more facet of the scapegoat. In his essay “On the Phenomenon of the Scapegoat for Azazel” in The Just Still Live by His Faith, Rabbi Eliyahu Munk notes that “All those Israelites who repent their sins out of love of G-d do not need the scapegoat to carry their sins at all.” This was a fascinating point to read as it echoed the ideas spoken of by Rabbi Aryeh Kerzener (Agudah Yisrael of Montreal) in his Shabbas Shuva Shiur. The gemara in Yuma 86 states that repentance from love of Hashem converts sins into merit – this is a high madrega! What other repentance is there? Repentance from fear. These sins, according to Rabbi Munk “are only being squashed…therefore the impurity created by such sins returns to its origin, but does not vanish from the universe.”

 The sins we atone for out of fear go from deliberate to b’shogag, by accident, and thus can be placed on the goat because their burden of guilt has been lessoned. There is, however, still guilt, still a sense of something that Hashem will want to punish us for, and thus creating only more Yiras Hashem. Yiras Hashem is good. It’s important. But Hashem wants our true Ahava. Hashem does not want us to repent because we want to be forgiven so we will not be punished. Hashem wants us to come to the point where our teshuva is truly for the purpose of coming closer to Him, because we love Him so much that we do not want to have anything that distances us from Him. Hashem is taking them away from us, ritually, with great finality so that, perhaps – ideally, we can see the path forward to pure Ahavas Hasham.

 I would love to go further into the thoughts shared by Rabbi Kerzner on the significant interchange of mitzvos and aveiros (he discussed how sometimes we don’t even realize that our mitzvos can also be aveiros), but this is now running long and we all have much to accomplish today.

 To conclude, let me ask all who know me for mechila for anything I might have done 😊.

In all seriousness, however, let us hope that we are soon in the time when we have true clarity on this ritual, but when the ritual is no longer needed or our understanding of Hashem is so clear and present that all of our actions are based on our ahavas Hashem. Until that time, let us look upon all of the mysteries of Yom Kippur, and Jewish life in general, with a recognition that there is always far more depth in Hashem’s perception then in ours.

 

Gmar Chasima Tova to all of you.

 

Wednesday, October 1, 2014

Conscientious Connecting

This Dvar Torah was written as part of a group that says Tehillim/Psalms together during the month of Elul (through Yom Kippur).

It is almost Yom Kippur, and I am worried. I would love to say that I am sensing the awe of the season and experiencing the trepidation of these days so beautifully described in the sefarim (Jewish books) - but my worry is that I am not. (To be honest, this same difficulty occurs to me annually.) I worry because I can’t remember what I did last week that might have hurt someone, let alone six months ago. I worry because so many of my transgressions are the one’s that are considerably awkward to apologize for - a nasty response, impatience, a thoughtless comment, being a bad role model, a judgement made in jealousy, and etc. I worry that I did no spiritual work in Elul. (I didn’t even have time to read the emails of this group until Rosh Hashana!)

On the morning of Shabbas Shuva, the Shabbas after Rosh Hashana, after I miraculously davened all of Shacharit and Mussaf (with no interruptions!), I was granted an insight into myself that I did not wish to have: I have been stuck. I’ve been standing still. I’ve used a thousand reasons to let my spiritual growth plateau - kids, full time job, travelling husband - but these were all excuses for myself.

As I thought about the time of year we are in, I decided to make this Dvar Torah personal rather than "scholarly" and write about the hardest words (according to the Ziz in the children’s book): "I’m sorry."

We have among our children, one child who has had an issue with anger management. For a few months, life was a series of ceaseless, somewhat violent, tantrum. They were triggered by random issues - such as the cruel act of serving chicken for dinner. At one point, after being particularly aggressive, the child sullenly blurted out, "I’m sorry." Very honestly, I replied, "No you are not. Don’t tell me you are sorry unless you mean it."

These were words I would live to regret. The child understood me perfectly, but, a few days later, after yet another meltdown, when I said that an apology was appropriate, I was told "No." The child then declared that I myself had said that I didn’t want apologies. The first few times the child said this (in different instances), it was said in anger. Each time I explained to the child that I had meant that apologies had to have at least some level of sincerity to them. Then I noticed that the anger had changed to sadness and longing. Over time, the child had begun to feel trapped in their own refusal. This child wanted desperately to apologize and didn’t know how to back down from the refusal to dos so. (Baruch Hashem, we’ve worked through this.)

As I sat on Shabbas Shuva thinking about the Dvar Torah I wanted to write, my mind kept coming back to this situation and how appropriate it is for this time of year. When I read essays on Teshuva (repentance), I am reminded all about the necessary steps (recognize, confess, regret and not repeat), and I always falter when I think of the commitment not to repeat the act. If I had stolen something, I believe I could honestly say I would never do it again, but so many of my transgressions are the results of thoughtlessness. (Let’s take an easy one - nail-biting on Shabbas, which I do completely without realizing I am doing it.)

Suddenly, from my parental experience, I have a new insight. I never expected this child to offer me a fully, clear and sincere apology and a promise not to have another tantrum or to never hit a sibling again. What I did expect was a conscientious apology, an apology that recognized that something wrong had been done and that there was something for which to be sorry. Similarly, this is why the first step of teshuva is basic recognition. Even if I can’t guarantee I won’t repeat a wrong action, if I never recognize that it was wrong I will never move forward.

As I mentioned, I’ve been at a bit of standing still in my spiritual growth. Oddly enough, writing about Judaism on a daily basis for JewishTreats.org makes it harder to always be charged to learn. On the other hand, like so many others, my davening increased immensely this past summer (which means I actually davened more than once a month) due to the situation in Israel. I tried to carry this momentum into Elul, but by the second half of the month I would find the sun setting and I still hadn’t found my siddur.

The last few days, however, I have been making a true effort. I want to connect. I yearn to connect, and yet it is so hard. Even when I have the siddur before me, I am often only saying words rather than having a conversation. I think that this happens to a lot of people and this often makes it harder for us to follow through on daily davening when we have so many other commitments pressing upon us.

Here too, however, it is about conscientious efforts. After a tantrum, the child mentioned above, would often just stand in the room I was in, wanting comfort but not knowing how to undo the damage. Little did this child know that just showing me a pleasant countenance was healing the wounds of our balance.

Last week, heading into Rosh Hashana, I was cooking with my eldest. He was making the salmon for Rosh Hashana. I told him about the first time I ever made salmon and the person who guided me through (for those who don’t know me or don’t recall - I do not eat fish, I think it is gross, but I prepare it for my family). On the spur of the moment, we decided I should call this person and ask her if she remembered the recipe. This friend and I haven’t spoken in several years as I am lousy at keeping in touch. When we spoke, when I heard her voice, I felt instantly connected right back to her as I had been years ago.

I share this because this is made me think about davening. When I do make the connection to the Divine, it’s a warm, wonderful and familiar feeling. If I don’t take the steps to get there, trying to daven, trying to do teshuva, trying to grow spiritually, I will forever be missing the connection.

Last night, after most of this Dvar Torah had been composed, I went to a class and the first verse that was quoted by the speaker was: "Seek out Hashem while He may be found, call upon Him while He is near" (Isaiah 55:6), and I thought, the more we call upon Him now, while He is near, the more we can carry that connection through the rest of the year.

Friday, September 13, 2013

I'd Rather Be Barefoot

This Dvar Torah was written as part of a group that says Tehillim/Psalms together during the month of Elul (through Yom Kippur).

Unlike the common stereotype of women, I hate shoe shopping. Come to think of it, I don’t particularly care for shoes in general. Any one who knows me well, knows I prefer to be barefoot most of the time. Perhaps that is why, for the last several years, I have been fascinated by the prohibition of wearing shoes on Yom Kippur.
Although I grew up in Pennsylvania, my childhood memories of Yom Kippur are all Brooklyn based, and one of the strongest images in my mind is of men and women dressed to the nines wearing bright white sneakers. How odd everyone must have seemed to the non-Jews driving past - but then again, the Talmud records that the rabbis of the Roman era wore sandals made of bamboo, reeds and palm branches (Yoma 78 a-b)...sounds very comfortable.
So what does this whole deal with shoes mean?: I understand fasting as a means of connecting to the spiritual over the physical, but what do shoes have to do with it?
Through various citations, the Talmud comes to assert that one who is unshod is afflicted (see Yoma 77a-78b). Ok, so the real heart of my question...why don’t we go barefoot on Yom Kippur? I, for one, would be overjoyed.
This is a particularly intriguing question when one recalls the fact that when Moshe approached the burning bush, God instructed him to remove his shoes. Joshua was similarly commanded by the Host of the Lord just before entering the land.
Why then do we not try to emulate these great men?
In both cases, the Torah states that they had to remove their shoes because they were standing on sacred ground, they were in the Divine presence. Perhaps God required Moses to remove his shoes so that while he was in the Divine presence, the ultimate spiritual Source, he could stay connected to the physical. After all, our physical selves are that part of Adam which God made from the ground, the adamah. 
Alas, the truth is that as holy and pure as we try to make ourselves or our shuls (or our living rooms, where many of us women daven), it isn’t all quite up to merit a shoes-off approach. In fact, one is not supposed to daven without shoes on unless one lives in a society where being barefoot is considered respectful and one would go barefoot in the presence of a king.
For thousands of years, almost all shoes were made of leather (ok, some places had wood). Now leather is made from animals and perhaps that is the key to the reason that LEATHER shoes, not all shoes are prohibited.
Moses needed to be barefoot in order to stay connected. When I am davening, I am far from being at risk of connecting so strongly to the ultimate source that my neshama, my spiritual essence, may not wish to stay with my guf (body).  I should only be at 1/100th of that level! But on Yom Kippur I want to connect to the greatest spiritual part that is within me, and therefore I refrain from that connection coming from my animalistic side (as represented by the leather). The issue of shoes on Yom Kippur, the affliction we must make, is not about comfort. It is about the leather itself. On Yom Kippur we are meant to be striving to be like angels - pure spirituality. In seeking to enhance the spiritual, one does not want to be tied down by one’s more animalistic nature.

Thursday, September 12, 2013

Do I Let Him Fast?

Most people look at Yom Kippur with some trepidation about fasting. Perhaps they check the weather, hoping that it will not be too hot, or create strategies on the best ways to make it through the day. That’s an adult view of fasting.

My son, who is now nine, has a different perspective. Each year he asks me if he can also fast, and each year I tell him that it is not healthy for a child to fast - especially one with his metabolism. When he asks, I recall my own youthful enthusiasm for fasting and the friendly competition that used to spring up between the cousins in our family.

I’ve learned a lot about Jewish law since I was a child, and my son is benefiting from a full Jewish education; so this year, as we began to speak about the holidays, he made certain that I remembered that, according to the Shulchan Aruch, the Code of Jewish Law, a child should begin practising to fast at the age of nine. As he explained to me, this means fasting until mid-day, although I have also read that it is best to begin with waiting an extra hour or so before breakfast on Yom Kippur morning. From my point of view, it means that my son is no longer a young child; I must not only learn to let him spread his wings, but teach him how to do so as well.

Until now, following the guidelines of tradition, there has only been one Yom Kippur restriction that I have required my children to observe - the prohibition of wearing leather shoes. Of the five Yom Kippur restrictions (food/drink, washing, anointing, wearing leather shoes, and marital relations), only the wearing of leather shoes is considered not to have an effect on children’s health. My children, of course, are also incredibly enthusiastic about not washing on Yom Kippur (or making certain to wash only up to the first knuckles), but I think that might be for other reasons than piety.

I’ve always liked fasting on Yom Kippur. Granted, I always head into the holiday with anxiety about it, wondering if it will be difficult. Afterward, however, there is a tremendous sense of accomplishment. More than that, most years, the act of fasting has actually helped me to focus on my spiritual, rather than my physical, needs. Not at the beginning of the day, mind you. Then, in addition to the Yom Kippur prayers, I am often focussed on telling myself that I am not hungry and planning how I will survive the long day. Rather, somewhere in the early afternoon, my need for physical satisfaction wanes. I gain a sense of myself as more than a Diet Coke craving chocoholic. Perhaps the most fascinating fact about the Yom Kippur fast to me has always been my lack of interest in breaking the fast afterward. I’m just not hungry. In fact, I often wish it wasn’t yet over.

Will I let my son fast this year? The choice is no longer really mine. As much as I may wish to deny it, I do see a difference in him from last year. He makes choices for himself and assumes opportunities for independence. The choice I do have is to make his practice fasting something meaningful rather than an opportunity to gloat in front of his younger sisters. Perhaps I will invite him to join me in some of the prayers or ask him to use that extra hour before he eats to contemplate what Yom Kippur means to him. And since it is the Day of Atonement, perhaps I will use that time to apologize to God for all the times I forget to thank Him for this wonderful child.