Thursday, December 27, 2018

In Just Five Verses (Shemos)


The narratives of the Torah, from creation through the Exodus, cover an incredibly intense time period. A lot of things happen and so taking an extra look at where the text focuses can lead to particularly interesting. For instance, the dialogue between Yosef and Yehuda is repeated. On the other hand, moments that one would expect to be discussed in detail are covered only briefly. An excellent example of this brevity is the incident when Moshe slays an Egyptian taskmaster and is called out on it and ends up fleeing Pharaoh and Egypt. All of that takes place in five verses.

11: Some time after that, when Moses had grown up, he went out to his kinsfolk and witnessed their labors. He saw an Egyptian beating a Hebrew, one of his kinsmen.
12: He turned this way and that and, seeing no one about, he struck down the Egyptian and hid him in the sand.
13:When he went out the next day, he found two Hebrews fighting; so he said to the offender, “Why do you strike your fellow?”
14: He retorted, “Who made you chief and ruler over us? Do you mean to kill me as you killed the Egyptian?” Moses was frightened and thought: Then the matter is known!
15: Now the priest of Midian had seven daughters. They came to draw water and filled the troughs to water their father’s flock;

The verses of Shemos 2:11-15 are rather surprising really. From the narrative perspective Moshe has just been set up for a charmed life as the adopted son of Pharaoh’s daughter – and that life is totally ignored in the text because it was all false. Instead, the Torah jumps right into a scene of murder! One almost feels as if one has been dropped into a vigilante movie scene.

These verses, however, are a pivotal moment in Moshe’s life. (Ok, there were a lot of pivotal moments.) One could read this text and cheer at Moshe for stepping up for justice, rather than look at it as his casting away of his Egyptian privilege, but this was the moment that he broke his connection to the Egyptian he was being groomed to be. The fact that the text says he “went out to his brethren” implies his awareness of his connection to the Hebrews. Interestingly, the Torah does not reveal exactly how much he understood this connection. At this point in his life he might have felt only the vague connection of knowing he was of Hebraic origin or he might have really wished to know his biological family. Perhaps he was drawn to his heritage but did not know how to come closer to the Hebrews  since his position in life was so far from theirs.

In a way, it is reminiscent of the position of so many Jews in the last few generations who were raised away from their heritage. Many have sought a way to connect, but not all of them were able to take those steps.

In a book based on the commentaries of the Ramchal, there is an interesting idea that explains that the reason that Pharaoh wanted to kill Moshe was that when Pharaoh heard that Moshe had spoken the holy name of God (Midrashic explanation for how the taskmaster died), Pharaoh understood that Moshe was still attached to the kedusha (holiness) that was an anathema to the avodah zarah that was the foundation of Egyptian life. First, he recognizes his connection to the Hebrew slaves, his brethren, then he connects to kedusha.

But the next day, his sudden elevation to a connection with the Jewish people is not met with warmth. When he comes upon the quarreling Hebrews, he is rejected, pushed away and rebuked. Shouldn’t the men have been somewhat welcoming? You might respond that they were upset and were interrupted in the midst of arguing, but they appear to present a unified reaction against Moshe. You might presume that they responded in fear, but a frightened person would not be so confrontational. No, these two men were stuck in their places and were thus resentful and angry that a man they wished to perceive as Egyptian was showing such a deep connection to kedusha. Here was a man who was not afraid to stand up to the Egyptian world in which he had been raised, here was a man who looked at the Jewish world and saw brethren. Alas, it is easy to live a Jewish life and be afraid of the passion of another person. If we are honest, it's something that we see in our own era and not just in reactions to baalei teshuva and gerim but often to people who are judged as extreme in their observance.

So why was this important moment so sparsely discussed? I can't answer that. But I can enjoy this opportunity to speculate :).  


Thursday, December 20, 2018

When Jacob Summoned His Strength (Vayechi #1)


This week completes the annual reading of Sefer Bereishis (the Book of Genesis). A great number of important events occur in these final chapters, all of which have profound and lasting impact on the Jewish people. In a quick summary, Vayechi contains the blessing of Ephraim and Menasheh, the gathering of the 12 sons at Jacob’s deathbed, the prophetic blessings of the 12 sons by their father, Jacob’s death, and Joseph’s fulfilment of his promise to bury his father in the Land of Canaan. 

All of these topics are fascinating, but let us look at the interesting introduction of the first blessings: “It was after these things that Joseph was told, ‘Your father is ill.’ So he took with him his two sons, Menasheh and Ephraim. When Jacob was told, ‘Your son Joseph has come to see you,’ Israel summoned his strength and sat up in bed” (48:1-2).

At first, this line strikes an emotional chord in me. Jacob is old, he is sick, and he knows he is dying, but when his son comes, he makes a great effort to pull himself together. Many commentaries, including Rashi, explain this action as respect for the high station that Joseph had achieved, second to the king. Other commentators pointed to it being a demonstration of the importance of what he was about to say. For instance, the Daas Zikanim stated: “He [Jacob] did not wish to bless his sons while bedridden, as he said that the blessing of a person clearly on the brink of dying would not be considered as having been given by someone in possession of all his faculties.”

Perhaps, however, it is also a hint to the deeper relationship of Jacob and Joseph. For Joseph, whose final years of youth he missed, Jacob still felt a need to appear strong. Or, perhaps, he worried most about how Joseph would react to seeing him old and feeble since he was aware of the great tragedies Joseph had suffered and how much his youthful relationship with his father had meant to him.

Kibbud Av v’Eim, honoring your father and mother is not only one of the ten commandments, but it is a mitzvah for which there is a great deal of explicit halachic conversations. It is a mitzvah for which Joseph is often greatly praised, and perhaps here we see the beautiful depth of their relationship.

About Genesis 48:1-2, Rabbi Shimshon Raphael Hirsch writes:

48:1 - Above, where Jacob wants something from Joseph, he has him called. Here, where he wishes to give something to Joseph...he simply has him told “your father is ill.” He is not to be called, he is to come as a child, in the feelings of a child when he hears that his aged father is ill, and at this opportunity Jacob gives him that which he has to apportion him. Jacob, even when he is giving the highest gift, does not make much of a parade of it.

48:2 - Joseph does not know how his father is and does not wish to excite him, so he has him told just casually that he is coming to visit him, and only then has him told that he is there.  
In many ways, Genesis is a strange narrative of the beginning of the Jewish people. The relationships within are anything but simple and are often far from ideal. Jacob is in no way painted as the perfect father, particular in his actions favoring one child over the others. These two verses, however, teach a subtle but beautiful lesson about how wonderful a mature parent-child relationship can be.

There is, however, something else about these verses that grabbed my attention, particularly the second verse: “When Jacob was told, ‘Your son Joseph has come to see you,’ Israel summoned his strength and sat up in bed” (48:2).  Another way of looking at these verses is that Jacob the father was told that his son had arrived, but Israel - the force of the Jewish nation - knew that now was the time to pass on the strength and vigor of the children of Abraham.  This is why, in the middle of one verse, the name changes from Jacob to Israel. The sickly body of Jacob is invigorated by the soul of Israel to make certain that the holy covenant is passed down properly to the next generation.

Please Hashem, let me have the strength of character to have an ideal type of relationship with my children and that I can be a proper conduit of the beautiful blessings of my Jewish ancestors.

Thursday, December 13, 2018

Stronger Because of You (Vayigash #1)

“And the news was heard in Pharaoh’s house saying: ‘Joseph’s brothers have come.” Pharaoh and his servants were pleased” (45:16). Thus concludes the reunion of Joseph and his brothers.

This simple, seemingly transitional, verse tells us a great deal about the respect that Joseph earned in Egypt. From the narrative of the Torah, one sees that he was an outstanding politician, and while, like all politicians, he obviously knew how to handle people and deal with authority, he also displayed tremendous foresight for the benefit of those under his care. Joseph is described as a fair leader and a man who maintained his morality even in difficult times. Such inner strength is a character trait that I think most of us wish to see more of in our modern political leaders.

Another frequently discussed theme of the story of Joseph is his unwavering emunah (faith). Even as he is reunited with his brothers, deep in an emotional moment, he affirms his belief that everything that has occurred to him has been part of God’s plan. It is, in truth, a level of emunah that I think many Jews today deeply wish to attain but certainly feel far away from.

There is tremendous power in the apex of this narrative - the moment when Joseph reveals himself. This section of the Torah builds to an incredible sense of anticipation: “Joseph could no longer control himself before all his attendants, and he cried out, ‘Have everyone withdraw from me!’ So there was no one else about when Joseph made himself known to his brothers. His sobs were so loud that the Egyptians could hear, and so the news reached Pharaoh’s palace” - 45:1-2). 

Perhaps we could look at this text with a different perspective than simple family reunion: How relieved Joseph must have been to finally be among his own people. Not just the joy of being reunited with his brothers, not just the excitement of seeing his father, and not just the affirmation of his belief that God had a plan, but rather the recognition that finally he would be among people who shared his beliefs, his culture and his language. In fact, the Midrash (Genesis Rabbah 93:10, cited by Rashi) relates that Joseph revealed himself to his brothers in Hebrew.

Recently I attended a four-day course in London. There was one other Jewish participant at the program, a delightful woman from El Salvador who was strongly affiliated but not specifically religious. As much as I enjoyed the program, I spent a significant amount of the mealtimes explaining to people why my meals were different, a conversation that often segued into larger discussions about religious beliefs and traditional life. It was fascinating for me particularly in that, as an East Coast Jew, I am used to people knowing at least a little something, but many of these international students had never seen special kosher meals before. And while I have always enjoyed being an ambassador of Judaism, arriving at my hosts’ home for Shabbat was a great relief. I was now in my natural element, where I didn’t have to explain my food choices, or why I didn’t shake hands, or feel as if I stood out for my way of dress.

Joseph did take on the semblance of an Egyptian while he lived in Egypt, but one can imagine that he never felt as if he was in his own skin, so to speak. Even as he rose through the ranks, he was always, in his own mind, an outsider. And the only way that he could shed that feeling of being different was by being together with his own kind. Revealing himself to his brothers was not just a joy, but it was also an internal pleasure of simply acknowledging one’s true self.

Joseph’s life in Egypt is a journey that most people today can relate to. Most of us live in foreign lands, and we have grown up steeped in two cultures - our Jewish world and our national identities. Most of us are not rising political leaders, but all of us have an obligation to remember our values, our morals, and our faith, no matter what situation we are put in. As important as this inner strength is, however, we should never forget the necessity of the strength we gain from being part of a community.

Perhaps one could look at Pharaoh’s reaction to the news of the arrival of Joseph’s brothers in a different light. Pharaoh and his servants knew that they could trust Joseph, knew that he was working for their benefit and that he took his responsibilities seriously. Perhaps now they saw that Joseph would be an even stronger leader for having reconnected with the Children of Israel.

Friday, November 16, 2018

Impact (Vayetzei)

The second verse of this week’s parsha begins “Va'yiphgah Bamakom, and he [Yaakov] came upon the place. . .” (28:11). If you are reading the parsha in English, this language may not seem strange, but the word va'yiphgah is actually a bit odd. In fact, if one were to look the root pey gimmel ayin in a Hebrew dictionary, one would find a strange assortment of translations, ranging from encountering someone to being hurt or struck. (Indeed, in modern usage, a piguah is an unexpected attack.)

The implication of the word yiphgah in the context of encountering someone is that of an unexpected meeting. It is what we today might call “bumping into someone,” which explains how it can also mean being hurt. There is an element of impact to the meeting.

Rabbi Shimshon Raphael Hirsch actually brings this idea by stating that the phrase Va’yiphgah Bamakom “cannot simply mean he chanced to come to a place…[it] never mean just a meeting, but always a meeting where the one makes an important impression on the other. Hence it is also used for the intentional going to meet with weapons, or to make a request, to attack or to urge. So that here, too, it must have been a place to which he had been meaningfully attracted and held.”
The rest of the chapter of the text describes Yaakov making a pillow of stones for himself, going to sleep and dreaming of angels travelling up and down a ladder that stretches to Heaven. This is followed by a promise of Divine protection. Until this moment, Yaakov has been Yitzchak’s son. And while he has secured the birthright and received his father’s blessing, this is his first direct encounter with Hashem and the moment when it seems fully determined that he can be the heir to the blessings of Avraham and Yitzchak. Certainly, this fulfills Rav Hirsch’s understanding of the place having a striking impact upon Yaakov!

The words of the Torah are written for all generations, and I cannot help but think that the term yiphga has its own resonance in our own time. Yaakov’s arrival at the place of his dream has an impact on the entire history of the Jewish people and therefore the world. Yaakov wakes from his dream and recognizes the holiness of the place and vows that if all that he has dreamt really does come to pass then he will accept God as his Divine Master - which is what happened.

How often are we in our own lives given an experience that could and should impact us, but we allow the opportunity to build our connection with Hashem to dissipate. Perhaps we can learn from this section of the Torah that when we encounter an unexpected moment or place of holiness, we must grab on to it and let it make a lasting impact upon us.

Thursday, November 8, 2018

The History Lesson That Never Ends (Parsha Toldos)


Although it is a basic tenant of traditional Judaism that there are no words wasted in the Torah, many of us can recognize certain passages that we glance over because they seem simple or too familiar. One such is the narrative of Isaac and Rebecca travelling to Gerar - perhaps because it is the third iteration of “my wife is my sister” - and the detailing of the activity around wells being dug by Isaac’s servants. It is all the more easily passed over as it is sandwiched between the exciting narratives of the sale of the birthright from Esau to Jacob and the drama of Isaac’s blessings to his sons.

But the events are not without significance, and, like all of the Torah, this section has an impact even unto our generation. After their full identity as a family was discovered, “Avimelech commanded all the people saying: ‘He that touches this man or his wife shall surely be put to death’” (26:11). Then Isaac settles and grows wealthy, which seems to cause a chain reaction: “The Philistines became jealous of him. And all the wells which the servants of his father had dug in the days of Avraham his father, the Philistines had closed them up and filled them with earth. Avimelech then said to Isaac: ‘Go away, for you have become much greater than us’” (26: 14-16). Isaac accepted Avimelech’s request, left the city and continued to be harassed. He dug a well and the Philistine herdsman - not the men of the city who had seen him grow wealthy - claimed it as their own. This happened twice, and then “he moved away from there and dug another well, and over that they did not quarrel” (26:22).

Rabbi Shimshon Raphael Hirsch, writing with his 19th century perspective, commented thus on the Philistine hostility: ...How the envy and jealousy of the nations who find the Jews well-to-do....send them out of their countries – may form not the least of God’s method for our salvation. Who can tell how easily Isaac, in the hustle and bustle of managing his great wealth, and in the prominent civic position he won through it, might not have given himself up to it more than would be seemly for the son of Abraham and the nearer of his spiritual heritage, had not the jealousy of the Philistines driven him again into isolation...

The message Rabbi Hirsch was communicating is clear. It’s one we have seen replayed over and over throughout our generations. A nation invites us in or welcomes Jewish settlement, but when we get too comfortable or wealthy...then we are not only expelled, but all that we have done that has benefited that nation is forgotten or credited to others.

It would be lovely if this was a new thought, but it was hard to look at this week’s parsha and not think about anti-Semitism and the uncertain times we are facing right now where every other Jewish social media article is about the anti-Semitism on both sides of the political spectrum. And yet, the fate of our people to be subjected to the trauma of national rivalry is not only in the parsha in Isaac’s dealings with Gerar, but both at the beginning and end of the parsha as well.

Parshas Toldos opens with Rebecca conceiving twins who struggle so fiercely in utero that she seeks Divine guidance on her troubles. The response she receives is that: “Two nations are in your womb. Two separate people shall issue from your body. One people shall be mightier than the other, and the older shall serve the younger” (25:23). This is the first prophecy of the national rivalry to come.

At the end of the parsha, Isaac gives his sons the following blessings:

To Jacob: “Let peoples serve you, and nations bow down to you. Be lord over your brothers, and let your mother's sons bow down to you. Cursed be every one that curses you, and blessed be every one that blesses you” (27:19).

To Esau: “And by your sword shall you live, and you shall serve your brother; and it shall come to pass when you shall break loose, that you shall shake his yoke from off your neck” (27:40).

Once again, national rivalry is predicted.

In a recent online conversation in a more political group, a poll was taken asking what members believed was responsible for the recent increase in anti-Semitism. The answers were all political - ranging on both sides of the spectrum. Perhaps the answer is far less simple. Anti-Semitism is so nonsensical, so hypocritical, and so ceaselessly pervasive that it can only chalk it up to Divine plan ... Trying to intellectually dissect anti-Semitism leads to madness.

Our great ancestors did not know that they were setting a pathway for history - if they had they could not have functioned as human beings. But we have the tools to look back and see how the world has been structured. When the people of Gerar and the herdsmen of Gerar acted from envy and jealousy, Esau and Jacob were not small children. They were with their parents. They were witness to the actions of the world, and who knows what lessons Esau learned from their actions about how to win, how to acquire, and how to drive an enemy away. These are the tools his descendants use to bring themselves to ascendance. While we are dealing with the rage of Ishmael (a subject for another time), we are seeing Esau struggling to remind us what happens when we do not live up to our precious birthright blessing.



Friday, November 2, 2018

Bringing Opposites Together (Chayei Sarah #1)

When my husband and I were dating, we often joked about certain parts of our personalities that made us different. I was the “Capricorn” (Hebrew month of Tevet) to his “Cancer” (Hebrew month of Tammuz), which we most often saw defined as head-over-heart and heart-over-head. In many ways we were an excellent case of “opposites attract.” Similarly - sort of - the courtship story of Isaac and Rebecca, which begins in this week’s parsha and continues next week, is about a Divine pairing of opposites. It is also a narrative from which our current society can learn a beautiful and important lesson.

Of the three patriarchs, Isaac is the one about whom there is the least text in the Torah. He is a man of steadiness. Unlike Abraham, his father, and Jacob, his son, Isaac made no grand journeys. The furthest he travelled was to Gerar, a city where his parents had already made an impact. Isaac was the son of a man known for his acts of chesed, loving-kindness, and a woman renowned for her wisdom and modesty. His persona is of an introvert, focused on preserving his father’s legacy. Holding onto a traditional path, he wanted to pass what he had on to his eldest son. Isaac is considered in Judaic texts to be the embodiment of the middah of gevurah, inner strength.

Rebecca, on the other hand, is a woman of movement and change. The daughter of an avaricious con man (according to the Midrash), she did not let her family’s corruption hold her back. Nor did traditions constrain her. When a man (Eliezer) spoke to her at the well, she immediately responded, provided him with water, and brought water for his camels. She doesn’t hesitate to follow Eliezer to marry a man she’s never met. When her twins fight within her, she demands an answer why, and when she sees a need to correct the path of events (who should receive the blessing) she takes action to correct it.

It seems that Isaac is head-over-heart and Rebecca is heart-over-head. This is significant because their union brought about the creation of Jacob, who is known as the embodiment of tiferet, splendor - a blending of gevurah and chesed that leads to emes, truth.

After the terrible tragedy in Pittsburgh this past week, there was a tidal wave of finger-pointing articles. Perhaps in the wonderful union of Isaac and Rebecca we can learn a lesson that will bring people together. From the bringing together of Isaac, a conservative, and Rebecca, a liberal, the splendor of truth could be born, and from the man of truth came the Jewish nation, whose purpose is to be a holy nation and light unto the world.

In the wake of tragedy - may our people have no more - let us be inspired by Isaac and Rebecca and come together as the family that we truly are.

Thursday, October 25, 2018

Passing Judgement on Nations (Vayera #1)

Do we have a right to assess the values of another nation? Ok, conventional wisdom says absolutely not and that our judgement is blurred by our own cultural biases, but what about from a Torah point of view? The answer to this is not straightforward, but Parshat Vayera can provide us with some very interesting insights. 

The first outside culture dealt with in this week’s parsha is the infamous Sodom. The second half of Genesis 18 contains a curious dialogue in which Hashem tells Avraham that he has decided to destroy Sodom and Amarah, and Avraham argues with him: “Will you end the innocent along with the guilty?” (18:23). Avraham, being a natural people person and a man whose greatest characteristic is chesed (loving kindness), assumes that the region cannot be ALL bad. He then attempts to find some salvation for the city in which his nephew has settled. He slowly whittles his plea from 50 innocent people to 10 innocent people, but Hashem assures him that there are not even 10. Avraham has no further argument left.

Why did Avraham try so hard? He wasn’t ignorant of Sodom. He had interacted with its people, with its king. He lived close enough to hear of the nasty customs that, according to the midrash, ran the gamut of punishing those who tried to help the poor to torturing guests who sought lodging in the city. And yet Avraham still believed he could find innocence.

The second outside culture that is encountered in this week’s parsha is that of Gerar, a small Philistine kingdom to the south ruled by a king known as Avimelech. This is Avraham’s first mentioned interaction with Avimelech and the people of Gerar. Perhaps because he is moving south, the same direction as Egypt where he had discovered the pernicious character of their king when it came to beautiful women, Avraham once again introduces Sarah as his sister rather than his wife (although it did cause him a bit of trouble previously). When Avimelech claims the beautiful Sarah, Hashem comes to him in a dream and corrects him. The next morning Avimelech confronts Avraham with a sentence that I found rather intriguing: “What did you see that you did this thing?” (20:10).

Avimelech assumes that there is a reason that he and his people were deemed untrustworthy by Avraham. And Avraham had reasons, but they were based, perhaps, on his understanding of Egyptian culture rather than Philistine culture. Avraham’s response is a mixture of apology and explanation: “Because I said, there is no fear of God in this region and they will slay me on account of my wife” (20:11).  (Concept inspired by commentary of Rabbi Shimshon Raphael Hirsch). Indeed, Avimelech demonstrates a true and genuine fear of God.

In parshat Vayera, we learn that it is human to judge others. God did not rebuke Avraham for trying to hide Sarah from Avimelech, He simply intervened, and no one came to harm. And although Hashem proved to Avraham that the society of Sodom really was rotten unto its core, Avraham is certainly presented as praiseworthy for his attempt to save “even ten.”

Rabbi Shimshon Raphael Hirsch has a beautiful insight on Genesis 18:23, when Avraham asks God if he would ruin the righteous with the wicked: “Avraham put himself in the place of such an innocent person [the possible one among the many wicked] to be saved in the midst of the general terrible catastrophe. He feels what he would feel in such a position….and now he ventures to express the thought - whether perhaps the pain which the righteous would have to endure at seeing the terrible destruction of their fell-citizens all around them might not be worthy of consideration….”

Nations have character. The jokes about Irishmen, Germans, and even Jews, all have a morsel of truth, which is what makes them funny. Avraham made an assumption about the people of Gerar because of his experience with similar cultures - he was wrong about their lack of fear of God, but not wholly wrong about how they might behave. And Avraham was unable to see the  all-encompassing wickedness of the people of Sodom because he could not possibly relate to it, and so he tried to find merit for them. (Perhaps this is the Biblical source for those who so blindly try to excuse the violence of our enemies.)

As the Jewish nation, the Chosen People, we must learn many lessons from our great ancestors. We cannot blur all other nations into one. The Philistines were not like the Egyptians, even though they shared some cultural traits. At the same time, we have enemies, alas, and we must not assume that they view the world in the same way we do, as Avraham hoped for at least someone in Sodom.

There is only One Judge in this world, only One who can assess the ratio of goodness to evil, and the only One who can direct us to the right actions to take.